Elia Pleasanton

Here we go with our biennial visit to the Bay Area once again.  Last year, we headed down to LA to get away from the rain, but it seems like the rain followed us to SFO this time around.  Once we landed, it was straight to an In-N-Out for a double double before heading over to Pleasanton to meetup with Cable Car Guy and Cable Car Girl.  Always a pleasure to dine with them and catch up!  They suggested that we try out Elia in Downtown Pleasanton.  Never been out there and wow, if there was some snow, Main Street would look like something straight out of a Hallmark movie!  

Anyways, we weren't there to scout out film locations, rather, we were going to eat!  That we did with some appies to start including the Kolokithokeftethes (or Zucchini Cakes).  At first, I thought they were crab cakes and in fact, when I bit into them, they were firmer than what I would associate with zucchini.  This would be the result of mixing it eggs and flour.  I liked the texture as it was not too wet, so that the outside would crisp up uniformly while the inside had some body.  This was served some garlic yogurt on the side.

Next, we had the Octapodaki or Grilled Spanish Octopus.  This was my favorite dish where the large tentacle was tender and meaty while having a bite.  It was grilled until there was a light char on the outside which afforded a rich and appealing smokiness.  There was enough seasoning for it to stand on its own, but the addition of some pickled potatoes, orange wedges, carrots and radish in a honey mustard dressing, there was crunch, brightness and sweetness to balance the dish.

One of the most interesting things we had was the deep fried Smelt with chipotle aioli.  Now if you are into Chinese cuisine, deep fried smelt aren't anything new.  However, I've never had such a dish at a Greek restaurant before.  Well, I have to say that this version was very much like the Chinese dish.  The smelt were full of roe and only lightly-battered.  They were crispy and beautifully salted.  The side of lemon and aioli complimented the smelt with acidity and some creaminess.

Plated much more intricately than I would've imagined, the Seabass Carpaccio was presented as a bouquet of flowers sitting in a mix of lemon, orange, garlic, olive oil and dill.   Although not completely "cooked" by the acid, this ate very much like a ceviche.  The firmness of the seabass along with the high acidity made it less of a carpaccio.  It was good though, as the fish was fresh and the marinade was extremely bright, tangy and appetizing.

Continuing on with the small plates, we had the Kounoupidi Tou Fornou (Roasted Cauliflower) with garlic-chili butter, pimenton, toasted almonds, fresh herbs and crumbled feta.  Really enjoyed this as there was a real oven-roasted appearance and taste to the dish.  Hence, each cauliflower floret was smoky and had a firm crunch despite being cooked through.  I thought the addition of feta really added some body to the dish and creaminess.

We also had the Keftedes featuring lamb & beef meatballs in tomato sauce and topped with tzatzki.  The meatballs were super moist and meaty with a noticeable gaminess.  Personally, I love that lamb flavor but I can see how some people might find it overpowering.  As for the tomato sauce, it was pretty bright and tangy with background sweetness but a bit one note.  The dollop of tzatzki added some creamy brightness to break up the heaviness of the meatballs.

Of course we couldn't do without the classic Kalamarakia featuring Monterey calamari with fried jalapenos and shallots.  I have to say these were some of the largest squid rings I've ever seen.  Despite this, they were not overly chewy.  Sure, they had a definite bite, but the rings were still tender and the batter was crispy while properly seasoned.  I thought the side of chipotle yogurt to be a refreshing change from the usual tzatziki.  It was light with a slight spiciness.

My favorite part of any Greek (or Mediterranean meal) is the lamb.  So when the Arnisia Paidakia hit the table, I was super excited.  These lamb rack chops were beautifully charred (without burning them) with a smoky caramelization.  These were properly marinated with hits of garlic, lemon and earthiness from the herbs.  Best of all, the lamb was cooked to medium where the meat was still juicy and plenty tender.  This came with some roast potatoes, Brussels sprouts, campari tomatoes and latholemono (drizzle of lemon EVOO).

Continuing with lamb, we also had the Kokkinisto served with orzo, mizithra, diced veggies, romesco and jus.  This large lamb shank was braised just enough that the meat was super tender and gelatinous without all of the meat falling apart.  It was delicious due to the braising jus as well as the romesco.  There was so sweet garlicky tang going on that flavorful without being too strong with any one component.  Orzo on the side had a great al dente texture.

Other than a roasted lamb shoulder, my other favorite Greek dish is Moussaka.  Normally, I find versions that are heavy on the bechamel and low on the layers of eggplant and potato.  However, the one here was one of the most balanced I've had.  As you can see in the picture, there were defined layers of eggplant, meat, more eggplant, more meat, potatoes and then a proper amount of bechamel.  This all sat in a tangy tomato sauce.  Consisting of lamb & beef, the meat was tender with plenty of natural meatiness.  Eggplant and potato were tender without being mushy while the bechamel was creamy with the unmistakable taste of nutmeg.

With the Bucatini Astakos, we found a large lobster tail with garlic prawns with al dente pasta.  Due to the thickness of the bucatini, it was pretty chewy, but in a good mouth-feel kinda way.  It sat in a spicy urfa pepper lobster sauce that was almost like a creamy bisque.  It was definitely aromatic and briny, but also surprisingly with a lot of heat.  The lobster had a nice rebound texture while the prawns had a moist snap.

Of course we couldn't forget about the classic Kotopoulo Souvlaki right (Chicken Souvlaki)?  However, unlike most other places, the one here employed chicken thighs instead of breast.  Hence, there was much more meat flavor in addition to it being juicier.  There was a nice char on the outside, which made things smoky while the marinade ensured the meat was tender.   This came with vermicelli-bulgar, roasted almonds and arugula.

Going out with style, we had the Lavraki (Whole Mediterranean Sea Bass) with arugula, heirloom tomatoes, sumac red onions and roasted potato.  The fish was prepared well with the skin being mostly crispy while the meat was flaky and moist.  I think the fish could've been salted a bit more aggressively, but it wasn't bland either.  Some lemon really helped bring out the salt. In the end, we didn't end up ordering any desserts because we had our eye on Meadowlark Dairy just down the street.  So the fish was our last dish and it was a fine end to a really solid meal.  Proteins were cooked properly and dishes were composed.  This was a little more refined than the usual neighborhood Greek restaurant.  The prices reflect that too.

 

The Good:

- Well-prepared food

- More refined than other Greek restaurants

- Excellent service

 

The Bad:

- It does cost more to eat here, but the food quality did reflect that 

- Although there are parking lots nearby, it was difficult to find a space