With "Home of the Best Butter Chicken" prominently plastered at the entrance of Baba Chicken, it elicits memories of Buddy the Elf congratulating a coffee shop for having the "World's best coffee". Jokes aside, I really do like a good butter chicken and I was truly intrigued by that proclamation. Formally Showsaa Modern Taproom, Baba Chicken now focuses on accessible food in a more casual atmosphere. Jackie and I were invited to see what changes have been made and yes, the butter chicken.
I have to say their revamp of the interior makes the place a lot brighter and less formal. There is this sports bar vibe that is also reflected in its menu. Hence, we started with some share plates starting with the Kurkuri Gobi. These fried cauliflower florets were crispy (thanks to the rice flour) and cooked through. Yet, they still had some firmness so that there was no mushiness. Best of all, the spices really came through with a bit of heat. There was some balancing sweetness too.
One of my favourite items here is their Paneer Til Tinka. Essentially, we find paneer sticks coated with batter and 2 types of sesame seeds. They are deep fried and served with a sweet and spicy dip. These "fries" were crunchy and nutty on the outside with squishy and tender strips of fresh cheese. Texturally, they were already on point, but we got some earthiness from the spices and the dip just brought things together with sweet heat.
You maybe wondering why we ordered Fish n Chips at an Indian restaurant... Well, this wouldn't be the first time and really, I've yet to have a bad version. In fact, most, if not all of the fish n chips I've had at Indian restaurants are on par or better than dedicated fish n chip restaurants. This was no exception as the fish was super flaky and moist with a uniformly crispy batter on the outside. Fries on the side were the typical starch-covered variety, but they were crispy.
We were surprised to be so excited about a typical-looking order of Tandoori Chicken. Well, because it ate and tasted a lot better than it first appeared. No fancy sizzling platter here, yet, the chicken was so impactfully smoky and well-seasoned. More importantly, the chicken was really tender and moist. That was true even for the breast meat. They did this by par-cooking the chicken first and letting it rest, then finishing off on the grill before serving. This kept the chicken from drying out. Delicious.
Okay, here we get to the regular-sized Baba Butter Chicken. This was super rich and creamy that was not tomato-forward. With that being said, there was a hint of tang at the finish. Spices were prominent with pronounced earthiness. Not much in the way of spiciness, yet it wasn't lacking flavour. The big pieces of tandoori chicken nestled within were smoky and sweet while being juicy. I have to say if you like your butter chicken this way, it is one of the better ones I've had.
Contrasting the Baba Butter Chicken, the Delhi Wala Butter Chicken was more tomato-forward with initial tanginess giving way to much more spiciness. The tang was nicely balanced by the sweetness from the onion. It was more velvety than creamy, being less rich where the spices were also not as prominent due to the stronger tomato notes. The pieces of charred chicken were smoky, moist and tender.
To us, the Daryanganj Butter Chicken looked to be a hybrid between the Baba Butter Chicken and the Delhi Wala Butter Chicken. It was definitely more tomatoey than the Baba chicken, but creamier than the Delhi chicken. It was just as or more spicy than the Delhi chicken as well. There was a pronounced tanginess that was balanced by the cream, yet the spices really came through. This would be the most common butter chicken you would find at most Indian restaurants.
We had a few more curries as well including the Paneer Angaara. Wow, this one really packed a punch. This was probably the spiciest curry that we had and it was a good kind of spicy. Despite having a kick, it did not detract from the other components. Hence, we could still pick out fall spices and of course, earthiness. There was a hint of smokiness as well as tomato tang and sweetness. Loved the texture of the paneer as it was at its squishy best.
Going a bit off the board, we went for something different in terms of flavour and protein in the Methi Prawn. This was still rich and creamy with earthy and slightly bitter notes, thanks to the fenugreek. Furthermore, we definitely got aromatics from the base of onions, ginger and garlic. That offered sweetness, slight sharpness and nuttiness. As for the prawns, they were both plentiful and texturally on point. They had a nice rebound and natural sweetness.
As always, we complimented our orders of basmati rice with something more flavourful and could stand on its own - Chicken Biryani. As you can see, the rice fully took on the marinade from chicken. Hence, it was spicy, earthy, gingery and garlicky. Texturally, the rice was moist yet still had a nice chew to it. The ample pieces of chicken were tender and due to the marinade, the flavours had penetrated the meat.
To further compliment our curries, we went for a selection of breads. We had the Garlic Naan which was fluffy with a crispy charred bottom and edges. Nice chew on the inside too. On top, there was a wealth of butter and garlic, which made it delicious to eat on its own. We also had the Hari-Mirch Bullet Parantha which was topped with a considerable amount of chilis. It was definitely spicy, but balanced, so it didn't blow our taste buds away. Loved the texture of the bread as it was crispy and chewy. Lastly, we tried the Stuffed Naan in onion and also chicken. These were also fluffy with elasticity. Edges and bottom were crispy and charred. Both came with Baba Buttery Gravy and butter. Suffice to say, they were delicious.
Instead of ordering a dessert, we went for the Mango Ice Cream Lassi instead. So really, it was a creamy and refreshing mango lassi with a scoop of mango ice cream. The lassi itself was creamy, yet light at the same time. It wasn't overly sweet either. However, the ice cream took care of that. Considering all the heavy dishes we had, this was rather refreshing. Overall, the food at Baba Chicken is solid and yes, the butter chicken (all 3 versions) was delicious. Definitely a good choice if you were in the mood for the dish.
*All food and beverages were complimentary for this blog post*
The Good:- All 3 versions of Butter Chicken
- Place is a lot brighter and casual now
- Other dishes were solid too
The Bad:
- Food can take some time




























































