The Turning Peel

Ever since I visited Apizza Scholls many moons ago, we have seen Portland's pizza game level up exponentially.  One of the newer spots is The Turning Peel, which was actually not as new as one might think.  Owner Candy Yiu started experimenting with sourdough during the pandemic in 2020.  Her sourdough eventually transitioned to pizza dough and it has the benefit of being not as flimsy as typical Neapolitan crusts.  After debating as to which pizza place we were going to hit on this trip, The Turning Peel seemed like our best bet.

Before we got to our pizzas, we went for the Beet n Mint.  This was a fairly simple salad with cubes of beets with orange segments on top and fresh mint.  Nothing out-of-the ordinary here but solid nonetheless.  The beets were juicy with a sweet earthiness while the orange provided an extra layer of citrusy sweet tang.  It was in a red wine vinaigrette with EVOO and pickled red onion. The mint added that bright herbaceousness.

Onto the pizzas, we tried their Pepperoni Jalapeno Hot Honey.  Look at that crust, isn't it a thing of beauty?  There has been a recent debate as to what makes a great Neapolitan-style pizza where charring and leoparding isn't necessarily a prerequisite.  However, for me, I'm all about the nutty smokiness from this type of preparation.  Add in the sturdiness of the sourdough crust and we have a uniformly crispy crust that is well-seasoned and appealingly chewy.  We can't forget about the toppings on this one and it was a flavor bomb with saltiness, pepperiness, tanginess, spice, sweetness and heat.  Every bite was a blast.  Highly-recommend this one.

We went for the other highlighted pizza in the Truffle Mushroom.  Beyond the outstanding and consistent crust, this had the classic earthy and woodsy notes that was not overwhelmed by any cream base.  Rather, they merely employed EVOO with portobello and bella mushrooms.  This was complimented by fresh cultured mozzarella and finished with more EVOO and aged parmesan (we got it on the side).  You could imagine all the nuttiness and aromatics going on here.

They also have a selection of crust dips and we went for the Ricotta, Honey & Fruit.  This was a nice change from the usual dips we find everywhere else as this was lighter, but just as flavorful with sweetness.  Really complimented the sourdough.  About that...  We were presented with a loaf of Sourdough as we paid the bill.  It was a thank you for dining at The Turning Peel.  Such nice people and such a great product.  We will be back!

The Good:

- Excellent blistered sourdough crust

- Impactful flavors

- Super nice people

The Bad:

- Even though we thought flavors were strong, maybe just a bit more pepperoni would've put that first pizza over the top